Originally posted by GM Watch on September 28th, 2022
Growing failure of Roundup Ready crops provides opportunity to phase them out and adopt new methods and technologies
The cultivation of GM herbicide-tolerant crops may be regarded as a temporary aberration, rather than the revolution originally proclaimed by the proponents of these crops, a new GeneWatch UK report shows.
The report, titled “Time for the end of GM/GE herbicide tolerant crops?”, looks at the economic, environmental and social impacts of growing Roundup Ready crops and newer herbicide-tolerant crops, reviewing more than 25 years of experience with this technology.
Here are some of the issues the report covers:
- Roundup Ready crops do not have higher yields
- Blanket spraying of Roundup Ready crops with weedkiller leads to resistant weeds
- Patents and monopolies add further costs and prevent seed saving
- Demand for non-GM seeds and ingredients is increasing
- Growing GM crops risks expensive contamination incidents
- Impact of Roundup Ready crops on farmers’ choice, land rights and indebtedness
- Roundup Ready crops have negative environmental impacts
- Roundup Ready crops pose unknown risks to human health
- Roundup Ready crops do not help to feed the world or tackle climate change
- Industry responses to glyphosate-resistant weeds are not sustainable
- Numerous lawsuits
- Better alternatives.
The report says that the growing failure of Roundup Ready crops, due to the spread of glyphosate-resistant weeds, provides an opportunity to phase out the use of such crops and adopt new methods and technologies. It states that the priority should be to reduce and replace the use of herbicides, not to replace Roundup Ready crops with other herbicide-tolerant crops, whether or not these are GM crops or produced by different methods.
The report warns that it is particularly important that Roundup Ready crops are not pushed into new countries that have so far avoided stepping onto the “transgenic treadmill”, in which farmers are locked in to paying for ever more expensive seeds and herbicides. In seeking to expand markets for Roundup Ready crops into new countries, the industry is dumping a failed technology on them – a conclusion, incidentally, that the environmental historian Bart Elmore also came to after researching the promotion of the Roundup Ready revolution outside the US.
GMWatch highly recommends this report as a comprehensive and thoroughly referenced resource for anyone who still considers that GM herbicide-tolerant crops might serve some useful purpose – or for anyone who is aware of the facts but needs to persuade policy- and decision makers. It is particularly timely as a new generation of gene-edited herbicide-tolerant crops is being promoted as an answer to climate and environmental problems.
Full report: http://www.genewatch.org/uploads/f03c6d66a9b354535738483c1c3d49e4/ht-report-fin.pdf
Full report (low resolution version): http://www.genewatch.org/uploads/f03c6d66a9b354535738483c1c3d49e4/ht-report-lowres-fin.pdf